Dear readers
I do not know if you have seen my op Ed Al Jazeera today.
Here is my big takeaway.
The Kenyan election of 2013 can teach scholars, and observers of
democratisation numerous lessons. First, a completely successful
election in Kenya as well as other parts of Africa depends on large part
on processes with high levels of transparency, consensus, and a careful
chain of custody of votes. Second, technology must be carefully tested
far in advance of elections, and care should be taken to identify
weaknesses. Third, governments and civil society can work together to
create independent institutions with clear rules, and well-trained
voting officials. Finally, the 2010 Kenyan Constitution has helped to
create institutions and laid out rules to promote democracy, which has
already led to improved electoral outcomes.
For the rest, click here.
~WMB
Showing posts with label manual. Show all posts
Showing posts with label manual. Show all posts
Friday, March 29, 2013
Wednesday, March 27, 2013
Technology, Transparency and Tallying
-->
Two things stand out in the Kenyan General Election of 2013: IEBC’s late procurement of both services and equipment related to the
election, and the fact that all technology should have been tested and debugged
far in advance of the election. The failures that occurred were both
foreseeable and preventable. Of note was the failure to plan for backup power. Electricity
fails routinely in Nairobi, and is often absent in rural areas altogether. In
addition, the cell phones and biometric scanners were not procured until
approximately one month before the election, and were most likely not tested
sufficiently for either load or other stresses. Professor Makau Mutua asks whether the
collapse of the computer systems during vote tallying was due to incompetence,
technological illiteracy, or lack of adequate preparation. The most likely
answer is a lack of adequate preparation, combined with a failure to follow
good advice.
Despite the massive technological failures, it can be argued that their main impact was a significant delay in reporting the results, not the integrity of the election itself. Importantly, the physical count of votes was the final and official record of the election. The manual voter register worked well to identify voters at the polling station level. No vote count was finalized at the polling station level without agreement of the presiding officer and political party agents. This process was repeated again as all presiding officers reported their numbers to the reporting officer in full view of political party agents and observers at the constituency level. All marked and unused ballots were locked into the transparent tally boxes with final numbers. Those boxes were tracked from polling station level to the constituency level, and eventually flown to Bomas to ensure that the final vote was correct.
![]() |
| Edge of a computer screen |
Despite the massive technological failures, it can be argued that their main impact was a significant delay in reporting the results, not the integrity of the election itself. Importantly, the physical count of votes was the final and official record of the election. The manual voter register worked well to identify voters at the polling station level. No vote count was finalized at the polling station level without agreement of the presiding officer and political party agents. This process was repeated again as all presiding officers reported their numbers to the reporting officer in full view of political party agents and observers at the constituency level. All marked and unused ballots were locked into the transparent tally boxes with final numbers. Those boxes were tracked from polling station level to the constituency level, and eventually flown to Bomas to ensure that the final vote was correct.
The idea that manual
ballots trump electronic systems is widely accepted internationally. A
symposium on Voting, Vote Capture, and Vote Counting was held at the Harvard
Kennedy School of Government in June 2004 in the wake of the counting failures
in the Bush vs. Gore presidential race in the US. At that event scholars
indicated that best practices for a secure voting system include a hybrid
system that includes paper for audit and an electronic system for speed and
flexibility. Ironically, their study noted that digital systems can actually
produce more complex failure modes and concluded that paper ballots, carefully
tracked through a custody chain remain necessary to ensure accurate voting
outcomes. The Kenyan election of 2013 illustrates those conclusions well.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

